Carroll County Sheriff's Office

Proud to Serve and to Protect Carroll County, Ohio


CALL 911

Non-Emergency Numbers

  • Sheriff's Office: 330.627.2141
  • Direct to Jail: 330.627.2170

Real Estate Sales

List of Sales

Sale DateCase No.PlaintiffDefendantAppraised ValueLocationSellAmount SoldPurchaser
1/22/201918CVE29050The Huntington National BankChad R. Albright, et al$45,0002854 Ivory Rd, Carrollton, OH 44615SOLD$42,000THIRD PARTY
2/12/201918CVE29086PNC, Bank, N.A.The Unknown Heirs of Herman Bentley, et al$126,0001262 Mace Rd. NE, Carrollton, OH 44615CANCELLED
3/26/201918CVE29140Residential BancorpTaylor J. Norman, et al$90,0006085 Avalon Rd. NW, Malvern, OH 44644CANCELLED
4/16/201918CVE29177Bayview Loan Servicing, LLCDavid W. Laney, et al$72,0008135 Salineville Rd. NE, Mechanicstown, OH 44651CANCELLED
4/16/201918CVE2902921st Mortgage CorporationDuane P. Bowyer, et al$78,0008201 Chalon Rd., Scio, OH 43988SOLD$78,000THIRD PARTY
5/14/201918CVE29128Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSBCharles E. James, et al$96,000462 Steubenville Rd. SE, Carrollton, OH 44615SOLD$64,000WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY, FSB
6/25/201919CVE29225Bruner Land Co., IncWilliam Milner, et al$33,000Corner of Lorric Rd NW & Linden Rd NW, Minerva, OH 44657SOLD$36,000BRUNER LAND CO
6/25/201918CVE29198The Bank of New York Mellon Trust Co., N.A.Unknown Heirs of Richard L. Willis, et al$72,0009241 Arrow Rd. NW, Minerva, OH 44657SOLD$48,000THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TRUST CO
7/9/201918CVE29084Deutsche Bank National Trust Co.Samantha E. Colosimo, et al$90,0005100 Autumn Rd. SW, Carrollton, OH 44615CANCELLED
7/9201919CVE29226PNC Bank, N.A.Richard A. Keiser, et al$30,0003340 Lombardy Rd. SW, Sherrodsville, OH 44657SOLD$35,000PNC BANK
7/9/201919CVE29233Bank of America, N.A.Richard W. Leidner, et al$75,0009013 Blade Rd. NW, Malvern, OH 44644SOLD$87,000THIRD PARTY
7/30/201919CVE29227The Huntington National BankCarrie A. Fraser nka Carrie A. Mihal, et al$42,0008075 Swift Rd. NW, Waynesburg, OH 44688SOLD$28,000HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK
7/30/201919CVE29251Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSBShelly L. Film, aka Shelly L. Anderson, et al$51,0006982 Alliance Rd. NW, Malvern, OH 44644CANCELED
7/30/201919CVE29240U.S. Bank, N.A.John M. Phillips, et al$57,000205 Bridge St., Minerva, OH 44657SOLD$38,000U.S. BANK
8/20/201919CVE29224U.S. Bank Trust, N.A.Gale R. Boring, et al$39,0008087 Magnet Rd. NE, Minerva, OH 44657CANCELLED
8/20/201918CVE29199KeyBank, N.A.Therese A.. Beverly htta Therese A. Raines, et al$39,0003686 Steubenville Rd., Amsterdam, OH 43903SOLD$26,000KEYBANK, N.A.
8/27/201918CVE29140Residential BancorpTaylor J. Norman, et al$90,0006085 Avalon Rd NW, Malvern, OH 44644CANCELLED
8/27/201918CVE29084Deutsche Bank National Trust Co.Samantha E. Colosimo, et al$90,0005100 Autumn Rd SW, Carrollton, OH 44615SOLD$80,000DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST CO
10/8/201919CVE29315Metropolitan Life Insurance Co.Stephen R. Belopotosky, et al$60,0008373 Seeman Dr. SW, Carrollton, OH 44615SOLD$40,000METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE CO
10/8/201919CVE29297PNC Bank, Inc.Rebecca L. Neidig, et al$42,000740 Lincoln Ave. NW, Carrollton, OH 44615SOLD$28,000PNC BANK
11/5/201919CVE29296Wells Fargo USA Holdings, Inc.Beverly A. Luff, et al$69,0007348 Roswell Rd SW, Sherrodsville, OH 44675SOLD$46,000WELLS FARGO
12/24/201919CVE29330myCUmortgage, LLCBrandon F. Morrow, et al$66,0009161 Berry Rd NE, Kensington, OH 44427CANCELLED
1/14/202019CVE29251Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSBShelly L. film, aka Shelly L. Anderson, et al$48,0006982 Alliance Rd. NW, Malvern, OH 44644VACATED
1/14/202018CVE29140Residential BancorpTaylor J. Norman, et al$90,0006085 Avalon Rd. NW, Malvern, OH 44644CANCELLED
3/3/202019CVE29224U.S. Bank Trust, N.A.Gale R. Boring, et al$39,0008087 Magnet Rd. NE, Minerva, OH 44657SOLD$26,000US BANK TRUST, N.A.
4/14/202019CVE29251Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSBShelly L. Film, aka Shelly L. Anderson, et al$48,0006982 Alliance Rd. NW, Malvern, OH 44644CANCELLED
4/14/202019CVE29441The Huntington National BankPaul E. Durbin, et al$30,000316 East Grant Street, Malvern, OH 44644CANCELLED
7/14/202009CVE29512Tammac Holdings CorporationThe Unknown Heirs of Thomas J. Proctor, et al.$30,0001180 Bacon Rd Carrollton, OH 44614SOLD$32,001.Third Party
8/25/202019CVE29441The Hunington National BankPaul E Drubin, et al$30,000.316 East Grant Street Malvern,Oh 44644SOLD31700.00The Hunington National Bank
8/18/202019CVE29330myCUmortgageBrandon F. Morrow et al.$42,000.9161 Berry Rd NE Kensington, Oh 44427CANCELLED
09/01/202019CVE29454U.S. Bank National AssociationTimothy W. Zucher et al$42,000.41 Penny Rd SW Carrollton, Oh 44615SOLD$46000.00THIRD PARTY
09/01/202020CVE29508Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasurerEstate of Stanley Ray Hall, Deceased, et al$3000.Cashmere Rd, Perry Twp, Scio Ohio 43988CANCELLED
09/29/202020CVE29508Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasurerEstate of Stanley Ray Hall, Deceased, et al$12,000.00Cashmere Rd, Perry Twp, Scio Ohio 43988SOLD$15,500.00THIRD PARTY
09/29/202020CVE29487Freedom Mortgage Corporation Nickolas Helderman et, al $153,000.005239 Avon Rd NE Carrollton, Ohio 44615SOLD$167,320.00FREEDOM MORTGAGE
10/13/2020CVE29518Bruner Land Company George Long Jr et,al$30,000.008774 Cottage Rd Dennison Ohio SOLD$42,000.00BRUNER LAND COMPANY INC
5/11/20212020CVE29497WELLS FARGO BANK NAJeanette R. Orsetti , AKA Jeanette Orsetti , et al.$63,000.006040 Arrow Rd NW Carrollton Ohio 44615SOLD$90,722.11WELLS FARGO BANK NA
7/13/20212021CVE29724Consumers National BankChristopher W. Easlick ET AL$120,000.008232 Oakdale Avenue S.E. Amsterdam, Oh 43903SOLD$80,000.00CONSUMERS NATIONAL BANK
7/13/20212021CVE29698US Bank National AssociationJoseph A. McNutt ET AL$69,000.007099 Lark Rd NW Malvern, Oh 44644SOLD$83,215.00US NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
8/17/2021 2021CVE29759MIDFIRST BANKJedediah D. Lewis AKA Jedediah Lewis ET AL$90,000.006216 Hilltop Street SW Carrollton Oh 44615 👀SOLD$116,560.00MIDFIRST BANK
11/16/20212019CVE29251Wilmington Savings Fund SocietyShelly Film AKA Shelly L. Film AKA Shelly Lynn Film AKA Shelly L Anderson$48,000.006982 Alliance Rd NW Malvern, Ohio 44644SOLD$86,000.00THIRD PARTY
11/30/212021CVE29826Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasureKevin P. Depalmo ,ET AL$9600.0080 Arbor Rd Minerva Ohio 44657SOLD$9600.00THIRD PARTY
2/1/222019CVE29458Deutsche Bank National Trust CompanyMatthew Phillips, ET AL.$75,000.00650 Courtview Drive, Carrollton, Ohio 44615SOLD$120,000.00THIRD PARTY
2/1/20222019CVE29829Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasurerJoy A. Leglise ET AL.$66,000.00407 Murray Avenue, Minerva, Ohio 44657SOLD$52,000.00THIRD PARTY
3/15/20222021CVE29872Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasureDANIEL R. JOHNSON, ET AL$7500.008069 Walnut St SW, Sherrodsville, Ohio 44675SOLD$10,200.00THIRD PARTY
3/15/20222019CVE29422Fifth Third Bank Erin R. Roskos, ET AL$84,000.008471 Walnut St SW, Sherrodsville, Ohio 44675SOLD$66,000.00FIFTH THIRD BANK
4/19/20222021CVE29873Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasureBeula C. Krause ET AL$33,000.00753 Robertsville Rd. Malvern, Ohio 44644CANCELLED 3/18/2022
4/26/20222021CVE29873Jeff Yeager Carroll County TreasureBeula C. Krause ET AL$29,000.00753 Robertsville Rd. Malvern, Ohio 44644CANCELLED 4/22/2022
5/17/20222020CVE29585Wells Fargo Bank, National AssociationWarren E. Kelm, ET AL$180,000.0038 Shoshone Trail , Malvern, Ohio 44644CANCELLED 5/2/2022
5/24/20222021CVE29873 TAX SALEJeff Yeager Carroll County TreasurerBeula C. Krause ET AL$29,000.00 payment required at time of sale 753 Robertsville Rd. Malvern, Ohio 44644SOLD55,000.00THIRD PARTY
8/30/20222022CVE29943Alantica, LLCJackie Roudebush nka Jackie Salsberry, ET AL.$180,000.005179 Brocade Road SE Amsterdam, Ohio 43903

Requirements for Sheriff Sale Foreclosures

Sheriff sales are held Tuesdays at 10:00a.m in the lobby of the Carroll County Sheriff’s Office. All sales are pursuant to the provision of the Ohio Revised Code.

2nd Sale Date

There will be a second sale date for every unsold property. The second sale date will have no minimum bid. Although there is no minimum bid, purchaser is responsible for costs, allowances and real estate taxes the proceeds of the sale are insufficient to cover. The purchaser will follow the same deposit amount as the first sale requirements.

3rd party purchasers be advised: If you are the highest bidder of a property, the plaintiff has the right to reverse the sale and can buy the property back for the amount you bid. The plaintiff has 14 days from the sale date to redeem the property. The deposit you made will be returned to you.

Electronic Bidding

The judgment creditor and/or any lienholder(s) are entitled to submit a bid via email or fax prior to 4:30 p.m. the business day directly before the sale. The judgment creditor and/or any lienholder(s) bids are not disclosed until the time of the sale. This bid will be the opening bid. The Sheriff's Office will only give the maximum bid of the judgment creditor and/or lienholders(s) at the sale. The purchaser information form must accompany the bid.

Fax Number: 330-627-8915. Bids may only be submitted by the plaintiff and must be received by 4:30pm, the day before the scheduled sale.


If the purchase price is:

  • Less than $10,000 = Deposit of $2,000
  • Greater than $10,001, but less than $200,000 = Deposit of $5,000
  • Greater than $200,001 = Deposit of $10,000

Buyer beware that he/she may be responsible any and all outstanding costs.


When and where are Sheriff Sales held?

Sheriff Sale foreclosures are conducted on Tuesdays at 10:00am on listed dates.

Sales are held in the lobby of the sheriff’s office.

How do I find out about upcoming sales?

Sales are posted on the Carroll County Sheriff’s website and also advertised in the Carrollton Free Press Standard newspaper.

Can I pre-register?

The Carroll County Sheriff’s Office does not pre-register for sales.

Can I submit a bid before the sale?

No bids accepted prior to the sale.

Can I view a property before the sale?

The sheriff’s office does not have keys to the properties. The Sheriff’s office nor any affiliates have access to the inside of said property.

Where can I find a property description?

A complete property description may be found at the recorder’s office.

What form of payment is accepted?

Certified, cashier’s or personal check.

When is the balance due?

The balance is due 30 days from the date of the sale upon receipt of the confirmation entry.

Are there any liens against the property?

All liens are to be cancelled by the plaintiff’s attorney and a clear titled deed issued.

*All sales are “buyer beware”.